This cemetery is located on the north side of Number Six Honeoye Falls Road about ¼ mile east of the intersection with Five Points Road. This cemetery is also known as the Sibleyville Cemetery, Palmer Cemetery and the McFarlan Cemetery.
The tombstones in this cemetery were copied twice before. About 1930 a list of inscriptions was made by Mary C. Douglas with help from Anna B. Yates, both of the Irondequoit Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution. Another list of inscriptions was made in 1939 by Mary Moulthrop and Myrte Rice Haynes, also of the same D.A.R. Chapter. A combined list was made from these earlier records and a visit to the cemetery was made on September 25, 1992 by Richard T. Halsey and corrections and four additions were made to the master list.
| ARNER | Jacob; d Nov. 8, 1844 aged 43y Samuel, son of Jacob & Anna; d Aug. 13, 1844 aged 7y |
| BARKER | Amasa; d Aug. 8, 1820 aged 18y Richard; d Sept. 8, 1820 aged 52y Peggy, wife of Richard; d Apr. 4, 1843 aged 74y |
| BOUKER | Harriet, wife of Tyler; d Nov. 4, 1824 aged 37y Betsey, wife of Tyler; d May 21, 1850 aged 29y |
| BRANCH | Zephaniah; d July 25, 1822 aged 62y 11m |
| BROWN | John D.; d Feb. 28, 1842 aged 80y |
| CARTWRIGHT | Isabel; d March 4, 1829 aged 58y |
| CAVENDER | Mary, wife of William; d Apr. 16, 1855 aged 37y 6m 5d |
| CLARK | David; d Feb. 6, 1835 aged 55y 5m Anna Mere, wife of David; d July 21, 1849 aged 65y |
| DANN | Caroline J., wife of Sellick; d Feb. 7, 1845 aged 27y Jabez; d Apr. 28, 1808 aged 23y Sarah, relict of Selleck; d Nov. 20, 1836 aged 69y Nathaniel; d Aug. 29, 1832 aged 45y Elizabeth, wife of Nathaniel; d Oct. 6, 1859 aged 69y Phebe, dau. of Nathaniel & Elizabeth; d Apr. 16, 1837 aged 24y Rebecca, dau. of Nathaniel & Elizabeth; d Dec. 10, 1857 aged 46y Underhill; d March 19, 1816 aged 54y 8m 7d Underhill, son of Floyd & Mary; d June 20, 1826 aged 2y |
| DIKE | Martin L.; d Feb. 7, 1835 [Note: this inscription is on the opposite end of a "footstone" for Sarah Ann McFarlen and was buried for over a hundred years. It probably was a stone carver's reject and it is very likely that Martin is not buried here.] |
| HAMER | Joseph; d Nov. 9, 1839 aged 68y Deborah Roberts, wife of James; d Feb. 13, 1837 aged 21y 5m 25d infant son of James L. & Deborah; d Nov. 27, 1836 aged 3d Eliza Ann, dau. of John & Maria; d March 12, 1838 aged 5 weeks |
| HARTWELL | John; d Sept. 8, 1832 aged 71y Mercy; d Feb. 5, 1826 aged 63y Thomas; d Oct. 15, 1863 aged 78y Samantha, wife of Thomas; d Feb. 25, 1863 aged 70y 9m Amanda M., dau. of Thomas & Samantha; d Apr. 9, 1842 aged 26y |
| HILL | Arthur; Phebe Ann; Josiah; Margaret A. all young children of Joseph & Mary; all died Apr. 1858 Mary Jane, dau. of Joseph & Mary; d 1859 aged 12 [Note: no tombstones for the Hill family could be found during the 1992 visit.] |
| JOHNSON | Charles; d Aug. 21, 1872 aged 69y Phila, wife of Charles; d May 13, 1856 aged 55y |
| LEE | Elizabeth, wife of James; d Oct. 16, 1853 aged 36y Elizabeth, dau. of James & Elizabeth; d Oct. 18, 1852 aged 8m |
| MACK | Polly, wife of Andrew; d Oct. 14, 1836 aged 51y 5m |
| McFARLEN | Mary; d Nov. 7, 1801 aged 59y Joseph; d Sept. 9, 1848 aged 78y Joseph Seignior [Sr.]; d May 14, 1814 aged 94y Sarah, wife of Joseph; d May 28, 1841 aged 71y John; d Nov. 7, 1823 aged 26y 8m Deborah Ann, dau. of Peter & Elizabeth; d Apr. 1, 1854 in her 15th yr. Julia M., dau. of Peter & Elizabeth; d Oct. 17, 1836 aged 3m Esther; d Apr. 15, 1815 aged 18y 1m Sarah Ann; d March 22, 1835 aged 8y |
| MOORE | Esther; d May 5, 1823 aged 95y |
| NICLES | George M., son of John & Julia; d June 9, 1845 aged 19y 10m |
| REED | Hannah E., wife of Horatio N.; d Apr. 10, 1835 aged 23y 6m 15d [Note: this tombstone could not be found during the 1992 visit.] |
| ROBARTS | William; d Oct. 30, 1830 aged 64y Deborah; d Jan. 9, 1831 aged 62y |
| TORRANCE | Thomas; d May 14, 1842 aged 91y 4m Richard; d Sept. 11, 1852 aged 66y Betsey, wife of Richard; d Apr. 8, 1846 aged 55y 8m Lucinda P., dau. of Richard & Betsey; d July 20, 1839 aged 23y 6m 21d Lacy, son of Richard & Betsey; d Dec. 8, 1840 aged 18y 1m 18d |
| UNDERHILL | William; d Aug. 15, 1805 aged 25y Delecta, dau. of John & Esther; d Apr. 4, 1814 aged 6y 2m |
| WEST | Nathaniel R.; d Feb. 27, 1837 aged 50y |
| WILLIAMS | Eliza, wife & consort of Andrew J. of Avon; d Jan. 6, 1849 aged 38y |
Go to GenWeb of Monroe Co. page.