This cemetery is located on the east side of the Pittsford - Mendon Road, north of the hamlet of Mendon. This is on Town Lot #30 of the 11 Thousand Acre Tract.
It is important to note that the old lists of inscriptions for this cemetery are not correct. In the Aug. 14, 1921 issue of the Honeoye Falls Times was published a list by Mrs. Anah B. Yates that said that it was from "Old Mendon Grounds." This was later written that all the persons on the list were buried in the Old Mendon Cemetery when in fact the persons on the list were buried in many small cemeteries in the Town of Mendon. Thus the list by Mary T. Douglas dated June 10, 1931 and the list done in 1939 by Mary Moulthrop and Myrte Rice Haynes both contain many inscriptions that are in other cemeteries. This list was compiled by Richard T. Halsey in October 1988 with corrections sent by Diane Ham, Mendon Historian, in 2005.
| AYERS | Kezia, dau. of J. & S.; d Aug. 5, 1845 aged 2y 6m |
| BACHELDER | Lucinda; d Oct. 15, 1837 aged 17y |
| BASSETT | Dorothy, wife of Henry; d Mar. 19, 1824 aged 54y Henry; d Jan. 24, 1826 aged 55 |
| BENEDICT | Samuel; d Oct. 31, 1867 aged 88y 5m Dorcas, wife of Samuel; b Sept. 10, 1776; d Apr. 28, 1858 Edwin, son of Samuel & Dorcas; d Jan. 29, 1835 aged 16y William M.; d July 26, 1825 aged 22y |
| BRISTOL | Mary; d Jan. 7, 1875 aged 64 [stone missing in 2005] |
| BRYAN | Esther, wife of Henry; d Sept. 26, 1858; aged 69y Henry; d July 22, 1835 aged 50y |
| COLE | Polly, wife of Abram [broken stone in back of cem.; this grave was moved to Mendon Cem. and a new stone erected.] Edwin Augustus, son of Abram & Polly; d Mar. 4, 1823 aged 1 Sally, wife of Samuel; d Feb. 19, 1842 aged 46 |
| DANN | Catherine E., dau. of S. & B.; d May 2, 1851 aged 2y James, son of S. & B.; d Sept. 29, 1850 |
| D'GARMO | Catharine, wife of Matthew; d Nov. 5, 1823 in the 45th year of her age Catharine C., dau. of James & Julia; d Aug. 16, 1831 in her 1st yr. Harvy; d June 28, 1830 in the 18th year of his age James; d July 1, 1834 aged 25y John, son of Matthew & Catharine; d May 4, 1838 aged 20y Julia, wife of James; d Feb. 23, 1837 aged 25y Mary, dau. of Matthew; d Oct. 1, 1822 in her 21st yr. Matthew; d Aug. 3, 1826 in his 47th yr. |
| GRAYDY | Henry, son of Joseph & Eveline; d Oct. 22, 1845 aged 2y 1m 3d |
| HAND | Catharine, wife of Josiah; d June 5, 1842 aged 57y Josiah; d Sept. 30, 1848 in his 74th yr. |
| HUGHES | Volney; b Aug. 19, 1806; d Dec. 21, 1858 aged 52y |
| LANE | Samuel; "Friend nor physician could save his mortal body from the grave;" d Apr. 6, 1817 aged 34 |
| RUSSELL | Duane A.; d Dec. 24, 1882 aged 38y |
| ST. JOHN | Sylvia; d Apr. 16, 1877 aged 79y |
| SANFORD | Abigail, wife of R. M.; d Dec. 12, 1841 aged 40y |
| SARGENT | John; d aged 65 |
| SHUART | Lydia; d Nov. 2, 1843 aged 52y |
| SMITH | David; d Apr. 22, 1835 aged 32 Joseph; d March 15, 1835 aged 69 Joseph F.; d Sept. 8, 1830 aged 35y Mary A., dau. of Truman & Sarah; d Oct. 20, 1837 aged 8y 2m Mary A., dau. of Truman & Sarah; d Aug. 1, 1858 aged 16y 6m 20d Nelson; d June 20, 1833 aged 27y Nelson B.; d Dec. 1, 1862 aged 29y 2m 9d |
| WEBSTER | Margaret, wife of Milo S.; d July 7, 1861 aged 36y 2m 5d Mary E.; d June 2, 1860 aged 5y 5m 4d Milton C., son of Milo S. & Margaret; d Nov. 9, 1855 aged 2y 2m 20d |
| no surname | Betsey; [probably Betsey DANN] little Ada |
Go to GenWeb of Monroe Co. page.